503-785-3485
bill@conerlyconsulting.com
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
Conerly Consulting Conerly Consulting
  • Consulting
    • Approach/Philosophy
    • Sounding Board
    • Economics and Business Strategy
    • Assessment
    • Case Studies
    • Testimonials
  • Speaking
    • The Package
    • Topics
    • Testimonials
  • Writing
    • Businomics Newsletter
    • Businomics
    • The Flexible Stance
    • Blog
  • Industries
    • Banking/Finance
    • Manufacturing
    • Other Industries
  • Video
    • Speaking
    • Event Promotion
    • Business Planning
  • About
    • News Coverage
  • Contact
  • Consulting
    • Approach/Philosophy
    • Sounding Board
    • Economics and Business Strategy
    • Assessment
    • Case Studies
    • Testimonials
  • Speaking
    • The Package
    • Topics
    • Testimonials
  • Writing
    • Businomics Newsletter
    • Businomics
    • The Flexible Stance
    • Blog
  • Industries
    • Banking/Finance
    • Manufacturing
    • Other Industries
  • Video
    • Speaking
    • Event Promotion
    • Business Planning
  • About
    • News Coverage
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Credit Crunch: Latest Data Leads to Doubt

Economy

24 Mar 2009

Credit Crunch: Latest Data Leads to Doubt

  • By Bill Conerly
  • In Economy, Public Policy
  • 2 comments

We all know there's a credit crunch, right?  That's the basis for the latest (March 2009) Treasury bailout proposal.  So I went looking for the evidence, just to prove to you skeptics that there really is a credit crunch.  I looked at business loans from banks (data here), comparing all the post-World War II recessions.  Here's what I found (latest cycle in thick blue):

BusLoans

The data link above has a plain-vanilla chart, in case you don't like my recession-comparison baby.

In the current cycle, see that bulge in loans that peaks about 11 months into the recession?  I think the data are misleading here.  When the commercial paper market closed down after the Lehman bankruptcy, large companies shifted to bank loans, using standby lines of credit.  The corporations had been paying fees for the credit lines, and the banks were contractually obligated to make the loans.  I haven't seen any estimates of how big that effect is, but I think it works itself out in six months or so, and may account for some or all of the recent decline in lending volume–but we really don't know.

Comparability issue: in the old days, bank loans were the primary mechanism for short-term corporate borrowing.  That hasn't been the case for some time; there's a lot of non-bank credit out there, not reflected in the chart. 

I can imagine three hypotheses about this recession:

1) The recession was caused by a credit crunch within the banking sector
2) The recession was caused by a credit crunch outside the banking sector
3) The recession was caused by non-credit issues, and the drop in credit is just a normal part of the recession.

It seems to me that for the first hypothesis to be true, we should be seeing a much more severe drop-off in business loan volume.

For the second hypothesis to be true, we should see wider risk spreads in financial markets, which we've certainly seen.  (See Calculated Risk's credit summary.)

For the third hypothesis to be true, we need other triggers.  Candidates for the other triggers:

  • The drop in residential construction, as a consequence of past overbuilding
  • A collapse of consumer confidence, caused by falling home values and bad news headlines
  • A collapse of business confidence, caused by the above as well as regime uncertainty

It's quite possible that hypotheses 2 and 3 could be working together.

What's this mean?  I'm not convinced that the banking credit crunch is much different than in past recessions.  Businesses always have trouble get bank loans in recessions.  The tightening of bank lending standards in this recession is similar to the 1990 recession and the 2001 recession, according to the Fed's survey of bank lending officers (to see a chart, hit that link and then "Charts"). The point that data don't support the bank credit crunch hypothesis has been made by others, most notably researchers at the Minneapolis Fed.

It certainly appears that bank lending is not the central problem of this recession.  Tim Geithner's huge bank lending program seems unnecessary, given that bank lending isn't the central problem.  This is what I wrote for one of my consulting clients in December, before the Obama team took over:

The new Treasury secretary will
be Tim Geithner, currently president of the New York Fed, whose career has
centered around economic crises, including the Mexican crisis and the Asian
financial crisis.  He knows crises, and
that’s good, but his instincts are to put together a big bailout rather than
let anyone go under.  However, there
really are times when we want to let companies go under.  My judgment: his strengths match his
weaknesses.

  • Share:
Bill Conerly

    Comments

  1. David
    April 13, 2009

    Businesses objectives in acquiring a loan is to ensure that business operations continue till the revenues of the business ensures sufficient cash flow to cover operational costs. Working capital loans are ideal for companies or pursuing a new ventures or to cover short term cash flow problems.
    David from http://jumplanet.com the Get a Business Loan site

  2. siya pradhan
    June 10, 2009

    data client data business loan

Comments are closed.

Search

Sign Up For Our Newsletter!

View Latest Issue

RSS Bill’s Forbes Articles

  • The Labor Market Is Tight Despite High Unemployment February 19, 2021
    Finding workers is hard despite the high unemployment rate, because many jobless folks don't match the skills needed, don't want to shift occupations or prefer to collect unemployment. Business focus on retention should be top priority.

Testimonials

It can be difficult to find economists who provide good substantive information who are also entertaining and engaging. I received many enthusiastic comments about Dr. Conerly from members and others in the audience.
Molly Steckel, Idaho Telecom Alliance
AgFirst Farm Credit Bank has benefitted from Bill Conerly’s unique insights and perspectives several times over the past five years…his materials consistently cover the points that we agree on…he has been very well-received by our groups, and we look forward to having Bill with us again in the future.
Ronnie Hucks, AgFirst Farm Credit, Columbia
You made a complicated global picture understandable. I have received many favorable comments from those in attendance. I frequently heard comments like ‘Now I understand’ or ‘Wow, now I get it’ and ‘He was great to listen to. Thanks for bringing Bill to our meeting.’
Pete Van Sickle, Idaho Department of Lands
Bill is a delight and easy to work with. The client thought he was great and delivered value to their group. I would definitely recommend Bill.
Andrea Gold, Gold Stars Speakers Bureau
Our audience of local business and community leaders not only valued the economic data you provided, but they really appreciated that you made it applicable to their businesses, their personal lives and moreover – that you presented it in a clear and entertaining manner.
Scott Boyer, Mountain Pacific Bank
As you know, it can be difficult to find economists who provide good substantive information who are so entertaining and engaging. I received many enthusiastic comments from members and others in attendance. I was very pleased with Dr. Conerly and have recommended him to NCSTAE, our national organization.
Molly Steckel, Idaho Telecom Alliance
Every time you spoke, we got business.
Chris Rasmussen, Washington Trust Bank, Bank of the Northwest
Bill’s presentation was neatly balanced…rich with content.. and our audience really enjoyed his humor.
Bing Sheldon, SERA Architects
We asked Bill Conerly to look at one of the major factors limiting the growth of our business. He pulled together data from a wide range of sources, as well as his own extensive business knowledge, to give us an insight into when conditions would improve and how we could be ready to capitalize on better times. He did so in a straight forward, easy to understand manner. A year later it was clear that things had evolved just as he had forecast. Ever since then he’s been my go-to guy on how the e…
Len Ludwig, former CEO, Vencore Capital LLC
Bill Conerly has been an invaluable resource to our executive team and ownership by delivering superior, well-founded ideas that are critical to navigating the current economic climate within the construction industry. Bill assisted O.B. Williams Company with developing a strong business plan that we implemented 18 months ago. As a result and together with Bill, we are improving our position within our highly competitive market segment. We understand that navigating this current economy is indee…
David Wick, CEO, O.B. Williams Company

Get in touch

(503) 785-3485

bill@conerlyconsulting.com

PO Box 2188
Lake Oswego, OR 97035

Useful Links

  • Consulting
  • Speaking
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • Press
  • Contact

Social Links

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin

Newsletters

Copyright 2020 Conerly Consulting LLC