503-785-3485
bill@conerlyconsulting.com
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
Conerly Consulting Conerly Consulting
  • Consulting
    • Approach/Philosophy
    • Sounding Board
    • Economics and Business Strategy
    • Assessment
    • Case Studies
    • Testimonials
  • Speaking
    • The Package
    • Topics
    • Testimonials
  • Writing
    • Businomics Newsletter
    • Businomics
    • The Flexible Stance
    • Blog
  • Industries
    • Banking/Finance
    • Manufacturing
    • Other Industries
  • Video
    • Speaking
    • Event Promotion
    • Business Planning
  • About
    • News Coverage
  • Contact
  • Consulting
    • Approach/Philosophy
    • Sounding Board
    • Economics and Business Strategy
    • Assessment
    • Case Studies
    • Testimonials
  • Speaking
    • The Package
    • Topics
    • Testimonials
  • Writing
    • Businomics Newsletter
    • Businomics
    • The Flexible Stance
    • Blog
  • Industries
    • Banking/Finance
    • Manufacturing
    • Other Industries
  • Video
    • Speaking
    • Event Promotion
    • Business Planning
  • About
    • News Coverage
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Home Prices and Consumer Spending

Economy

26 Jun 2009

Home Prices and Consumer Spending

  • By Bill Conerly
  • In Economy

Some friends have been debating the role of housing prices in consumer spending, stimulated by two recent articles in the Wall Street Journal's Real Time Economics blog.  First, Charles Calomiris, Stanley Longhofer and William Miles wrote that effect of housing wealth on consumption is about zero.  Then, Atif Mian and Amir Sufi of the University of Chicago offered a differing view.

I am very cautious before throwing out conclusions
that have been tested in multiple ways over many years.  The wealth effect on consumption has been
studied since the 1930s, with fairly consistent findings of low elasticity (one
to three percent is common).  I quickly
scanned some macro-econometric books on my shelf (Michael Evans, Macroeconomic Activity, 1969; Otto Eckstein, The DRI Model of the U.S. Economy, 1983,
and Ray Fair, Estimating How the Macroeconomy Works,  2004).  All these guys, very
familiar with past research and deeply hands-on in their own model development,
have negligible to low wealth elasticities in their models.  Their work also spans several decades.

We must differentiate an actual wealth elasticity from
the method of funding consumption.  A
person who chose to increase consumer spending and who was acting in accordance
with a mainstream consumption function might well have used home equity
financing so heavily that it looked like it was housing wealth that enabled
consumption.  That's because  mortgage finance was a cheaper (especially net
of taxes) way to fund car purchases than car loans. Also cheaper to use an HEQ
or cash-out refi to buy furniture or take a vacation than run a high balance on credit cards.   In
addition, many consumers consciously leveraged up their balance sheets: lots of
mortgage debt to fund investments, not just consumption.

Mian and Sufi's most interesting conclusion is:

"… the effect of house prices on homeowner borrowing is isolated
to homeowners with low credit scores and high credit card utilization
rates."

It surprising that they find such a large macro effect from this one segment of consumers.  If they are right, here's the interpretation I'd give:  normally housing wealth has a negligible effect on consumption.  Then for a few years it had an unusually positive effect, as it allowed otherwise credit-constrained families to spend more.  But now that's over and we're back to normal  The transition back to normal is tough, but we will resume the old fashioned consumption function.  However, the Calomiris et al research disputes this view.  It's quite possible that their analysis, which covers a large swath of post World War II economic history, misses the Mian and Sufi effect because it wasn't just housing prices that stimulated consumer spending, but the combination of rising housing prices and readily available sub-prime debt.

In any event, I think we're headed back to a normal relationship now.  Consumer spending will move independently of housing price changes in the future.

  • Share:
Bill Conerly

Search

Sign Up For Our Newsletter!

View Latest Issue

RSS Bill’s Forbes Articles

  • Inflation Has Not Shown Up Yet, But It’s Coming February 25, 2021
    Inflation is muted, but not for long. Inflation is coming in the next two years, then will be followed by a boom/bust business cycle, or maybe two.

Testimonials

Bill’s presentation was neatly balanced…rich with content.. and our audience really enjoyed his humor.
Bing Sheldon, SERA Architects
You are a master at your craft and a favorite of our audience.
Jim Parker, UBS Financial Services
We asked Bill Conerly to look at one of the major factors limiting the growth of our business. He pulled together data from a wide range of sources, as well as his own extensive business knowledge, to give us an insight into when conditions would improve and how we could be ready to capitalize on better times. He did so in a straight forward, easy to understand manner. A year later it was clear that things had evolved just as he had forecast. Ever since then he’s been my go-to guy on how the e…
Len Ludwig, former CEO, Vencore Capital LLC
Every time you spoke, we got business.
Chris Rasmussen, Washington Trust Bank, Bank of the Northwest
Seems no matter where I go, I hear you talking – and always doing a great job with different material well tailored to the audience. Very impressive!
Alan Shiffer, World Vision
Bill is a delight and easy to work with. The client thought he was great and delivered value to their group. I would definitely recommend Bill.
Andrea Gold, Gold Stars Speakers Bureau
You made a complicated global picture understandable. I have received many favorable comments from those in attendance. I frequently heard comments like ‘Now I understand’ or ‘Wow, now I get it’ and ‘He was great to listen to. Thanks for bringing Bill to our meeting.’
Pete Van Sickle, Idaho Department of Lands
Dr. Bill Conerly opened our Ace Hardware Platinum Retailer Conference by helping our independent small business owners understand the current state of the economy in a straight forward and humorous manner that connected very well with the retailers I spoke with. Dr. Conerly provided information our retailers can use to lead their businesses. He connected with the audience and made a complicated topic understandable.
Mike Berschauer, Ace Hardware Corp
Dr. Conerly’s presentation and view of the economic conditions impacting the world of business is insightful and thought-provoking. His analysis and presentation style is audience focused and engaging, leading to the efficient development of follow-up activities by those in attendance.
Paul Ulrich, The Inteplast Group (plastic bags)
Thank you for a wonderful presentation. Everyone who heard your presentation was impressed with your analysis, and strong command of facts and theory. More importantly, your ability to weave together substance with humor, in a very dynamic way, meant our attendees learned and retained more information than we would have typically expected. You made economics fun and you left our members with powerful insights on trends and issues to consider as they prepare for the future.
John Aguirre, Oregon Association of Nurseries

Get in touch

(503) 785-3485

bill@conerlyconsulting.com

PO Box 2188
Lake Oswego, OR 97035

Useful Links

  • Consulting
  • Speaking
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • Press
  • Contact

Social Links

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin

Newsletters

Copyright 2020 Conerly Consulting LLC