503-785-3485
bill@conerlyconsulting.com
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
Conerly Consulting Conerly Consulting
  • Consulting
    • Approach/Philosophy
    • Sounding Board
    • Economics and Business Strategy
    • Assessment
    • Case Studies
    • Testimonials
  • Speaking
    • The Package
    • Topics
    • Testimonials
  • Writing
    • Businomics Newsletter
    • Businomics
    • The Flexible Stance
    • Blog
  • Industries
    • Banking/Finance
    • Manufacturing
    • Other Industries
  • Video
    • Speaking
    • Event Promotion
    • Business Planning
  • About
    • News Coverage
  • Contact
  • Consulting
    • Approach/Philosophy
    • Sounding Board
    • Economics and Business Strategy
    • Assessment
    • Case Studies
    • Testimonials
  • Speaking
    • The Package
    • Topics
    • Testimonials
  • Writing
    • Businomics Newsletter
    • Businomics
    • The Flexible Stance
    • Blog
  • Industries
    • Banking/Finance
    • Manufacturing
    • Other Industries
  • Video
    • Speaking
    • Event Promotion
    • Business Planning
  • About
    • News Coverage
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Credit Default Swaps: Self Regulating?

Economy

29 Jun 2009

Credit Default Swaps: Self Regulating?

  • By Bill Conerly
  • In Economy

One common proposal for the new financial regime is regulation of credit default swaps.  A CDS is like life insurance on a bond.  (Here's my simple explanation, and my view of what went wrong with CDSs.)  A good example of a call for regulation is an article by my friend Bert Ely, generally a supporter of market forces.  He proposes that CDSs should only be bought by parties with an "insurable interest."  The analogy is to life insurance.  If you and I are not related, you are not allowed to buy life insurance on my life.

I'm about to tell you how the CDS problem is becoming a non-problem, but first let me quibble about the life insurance parallel.  There's a reason that you cannot buy insurance on my life: it would give you a big financial interest in bumping me off.  That would be bad for the insurance company, and bad for my health.

I don't see the problem with respect to corporate bonds.  I buy a CDS that will pay me if Chrysler goes bust.  I guess that gives me an incentive not to buy a Dodge, but I honestly wouldn't know how to go about killing the corporation.  (The owners, though, were able to do it.)  So there doesn't seem to be the risk involved here that there is with respect to life insurance.

So how does the CDS market learn to behave?  The same way we humans learn most lessons: by getting hurt.  The Wall Street Journal has an interesting account of a CDS deal that taught a number of traders an interesting lesson.  Here's the gist of it:

There were some debt securities backed by subprime loans.  The principal (after some losses and prepayments) amounted to $27 million.  The volume of credit default swaps written against the securities was $130 million.  Obviously, most of the folks buying the CDS on this security did not have an insurable interest, they were simply speculating that the bonds would default.

One investment firm, Amherst Holdings of Austin, was writing many CDSs on the securities.  They probably had sold CDSs that in aggregate far exceeded the $27 million of bonds outstanding.  They were paid a high price, often 80 to 90 cents on the dollar.  That is, the investor who wanted to speculate that these bonds would not be paid off made an upfront payment of 80 cents, in the hope of receiving one dollar later.  Take these numbers and multiply by millions, of course.

Then Amherst did a very clever trade:  they bought the underlying mortgage bonds at full value, 100 cents on the dollar, a price that was tremendously higher than a fair market price.  Why would they overpay?  So that the bonds would not go into default.  All of the CDS money, the 80 or 90 cents times millions of dollars, that Amherst received for writing the swaps?  Amherst kept that money.  They lost money on the bond purchase, but more than made up for it by pocketing the CDS payments.

I love a clever trade that is entirely legal and honest.  The folks on the other side of the trade are crying foul, but I don't see the basis for their complaint.

Why is this trade good for financial markets, and good for the economy?  It reins in the use of CDS by those without insurable interest.  If a CDS had been bought by a bondholder, he would have shrugged.  He doesn't care whether the bond pays off or whether the CDS pays off–he's in the same position either way.  It is only those who were simply gambling that got hurt.  Now they have a reason to be cautious.  And their caution comes without a government regulation preventing the instruments from being used.

Why not simply outlaw them?  CDSs have a role.  They make financial markets deeper, and more liquid.  It may be easier for a bond-holder to reduce his risk by buying a CDS than selling the bond.  Or he may not want to eliminate his risk entirely, just reduce it a little.  The CDS offers flexibility.  Why allow unrelated parties to be involved?  It deepens the market.  More transactions, more volume, and generally more accurate pricing.

The bigger principle, as I explained recently, is that many of our past financial mistakes will not be made again.  Re-read what happened to AIG in my earlier post.  Ask yourself how many companies are doing the AIG think now.  I think we've learned that lesson.

  • Share:
Bill Conerly

Search

Sign Up For Our Newsletter!

View Latest Issue

RSS Bill’s Forbes Articles

  • Inflation Has Not Shown Up Yet, But It’s Coming February 25, 2021
    Inflation is muted, but not for long. Inflation is coming in the next two years, then will be followed by a boom/bust business cycle, or maybe two.

Testimonials

Dr. Bill Conerly opened our Ace Hardware Platinum Retailer Conference by helping our independent small business owners understand the current state of the economy in a straight forward and humorous manner that connected very well with the retailers I spoke with. Dr. Conerly provided information our retailers can use to lead their businesses. He connected with the audience and made a complicated topic understandable.
Mike Berschauer, Ace Hardware Corp
Your presentation was right on the mark. I received more positive comments about you than any other presenter. We would not hesitate to recommend you to others or have you back for an encore performance.
Bob Russell, Oregon Trucking Association
Every time you spoke, we got business.
Chris Rasmussen, Washington Trust Bank, Bank of the Northwest
The ratings you received from our banker evaluations were among the highest I’ve seen, which matched my impressions exactly. Your presentation style is quite engaging, you bring interesting and valuable content, and our ability to interact in a stimulating way during “Q&A” sessions makes you a valuable addition to any meeting agenda. As a bonus, you are a genuinely enjoyable participant in conference activities beyond your presentation.
Steve Yeakel, Montana Independent Bankers
It can be difficult to find economists who provide good substantive information who are also entertaining and engaging. I received many enthusiastic comments about Dr. Conerly from members and others in the audience.
Molly Steckel, Idaho Telecom Alliance
Dr. Conerly’s presentation and view of the economic conditions impacting the world of business is insightful and thought-provoking. His analysis and presentation style is audience focused and engaging, leading to the efficient development of follow-up activities by those in attendance.
Paul Ulrich, The Inteplast Group (plastic bags)
Bill is a delight and easy to work with. The client thought he was great and delivered value to their group. I would definitely recommend Bill.
Andrea Gold, Gold Stars Speakers Bureau
Bill did a great job! There were many in the audience who liked him and many in the audience who loved him! Bill shared pertinent and timely information with our audience of commercial real estate professionals and added interesting stories and a funny sense of humor twist.
Jana Knoll, BOMA Boise
Bill did a great job. We look forward to a continuing relationship.
John Hamburger, Franchise Times
Bill Conerly has been an invaluable resource to our executive team and ownership by delivering superior, well-founded ideas that are critical to navigating the current economic climate within the construction industry. Bill assisted O.B. Williams Company with developing a strong business plan that we implemented 18 months ago. As a result and together with Bill, we are improving our position within our highly competitive market segment. We understand that navigating this current economy is indee…
David Wick, CEO, O.B. Williams Company

Get in touch

(503) 785-3485

bill@conerlyconsulting.com

PO Box 2188
Lake Oswego, OR 97035

Useful Links

  • Consulting
  • Speaking
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • Press
  • Contact

Social Links

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin

Newsletters

Copyright 2020 Conerly Consulting LLC